Around the time I read the last Harry Potter book, I found myself asking the big questions, pondering the meaning of all of this. Such as, why will there be no more Harry Potter books?
This made me very sad, and as I said in the post linked above, my one consolation was the fact that surely I will come across some other books that I'll love just as much. I embarked upon an epic search for such books, and I will occasionally post about the results here. I would also love to hear suggestions. It's not necessary that the books be "like" Harry Potter or fantasy books or children's books – mostly I just want something that's really enjoyable to read, something that has a kind of sweeping scope that transports you to another place.
Well, back in August and September I read the His Dark Materials series by Philip Pullman. I meant to post about it sooner, but then I got sick and then I kept waiting until I got over that and to be honest I still haven't really gotten over that, at least not mentally in such a way that I am back to being the way I was before all of that.
But now the movie of the first book, The Golden Compass, is out, and I feel very remiss in having delayed so long. Movies change the way that people feel about the books...a bad movie might turn you away from a good book; a good movie might leave expectations that the book can't fulfill. (For a good example of the latter, see The Last of the Mohicans – still one of my very favorite movies, but the book, which I read first, is just...blah...maybe it is the glistening male bodies in the movie, but no, I think it's more...the book is boring. Bor-ing. Yawn.) And then of course there's The Dark Is Rising, my recommendation for people seeking post-Harry reading, but I understand the movie sucks. I haven't seen it yet....
I also haven't seen The Golden Compass. But I have read the books, all three of them, even.
And...I thought they were...okay. Just okay. I was not transported; I did not find them worthy of great obsession or discussion. If there was some kind of (anti-)religious agenda, to be honest it didn't really occur to me. I was surprised at some of the content (I have seen all of the various commentary in advance of the movies, but it wasn't really those issues mentioned that struck me....one of the things that got me, and which I haven't seen mentioned elsewhere, is...dude, those angels are toootally gay).
I also didn't realize that The Chronicles of Narnia had a pro-religious agenda, so there you go. Oh, and I think that Moby Dick is all about the fact that the author just had a thing for whales. No, seriously. I read the unabridged version for "fun" (ha ha ha) and there is this passage that goes on for page after page about all the different whale crap that is in this particular town....there's this whale-shaped door-knocker, that whale painting, and blah blah blah....dude just liked whales, if you ask me.
Um. What was I saying? Something about whales, and how they bore me, especially when they feature in books?
Oh, wait, His Dark Materials. Here's the pocket review:
Plot Summary: Skipping it as you can read the movie reviews. Some cool conceits, like the notion that the characters have animal familiars that function as their souls, but that's not really the point.
Harry Potter Replaceability Factor: 4 out of 10. Diverting only for the moment, totally lacking in the richness and texture of the HP books. Despite the Big Topics and the traveling across worlds and everything else that HDM offered, I still couldn't help feeling that, compared to HP, the HDM books were somehow...small.
Not-a-Harry-Potter-Ripoff Factor: 9 out of 10. Really not a ripoff at all. At least the first book, and maybe more, came out well before the first HP book. That does score it a lot of points as far as I'm concerned. I hate pandering....
Overall: I think my big complaint is that I felt so remote from it all. The things that happened, any danger facing the characters, didn't really impact me. I read it, but I wasn't ever really invested in it. Just....okay.
If I Were a Kid: Hard to say. I think I might have liked it a lot. The whole animal-soul thing probably rates really high with a kid who likes animals. And of course the whole kids-with-important-destinies thing would have played well with Kid-Me. I inevitably would have missed whatever religious commentary the books might have contained – no surprise, as even Adult-Me is so totally oblivious. There is some content in the third book, which I will reference only obliquely so as not to spoil it for anyone still reading, that I think may have actually gone outside of my decency boundaries for kids...and as someone who spent her childhood reading Stephen King and watching horror movies, I have really liberal decency boundaries....but then again, maybe kids would also not read into those scenes the meaning that I did. No more to be said about that unless you've read it.
Recommendation: Eh, go ahead and read it. I know this is a lukewarm review, but if your bookcase has been cold and bare since Harry's departure, this just might be the adventure series you've been looking for. Moi, I think I will reread The Dark Is Rising and watch Lord of the Rings and dream of better days....